[spectre] New Media Art Organisations in Netherlands lose funding

Wed Jun 15 16:58:06 CEST 2011

Heiko is realistic. Politicians are able to make these changes if they think
they can. That's a function of their electoral security (not the same thing
as a mandate).

Unless what a government is doing is illegal I don't see how the courts can
help. As the UK doesn't fully recognise the European Court of Human Rights
and is moving to over-ride it with its own legislation it is also something
of a moot point here.

However, lobbying is still important. Many of the organisations involved
will survive (if they were planning ahead they would have ensured they had
appropriately diversified income models) and be able to negotiate with
government and its agencies over future policy and funding. Here in the UK
Higher Education has been cut by 80%. Most universities will continue to
exist but are changing the way they work. They are also lobbying behind the
scenes to ameliorate certain affects and alter policy where they can. The
same is going on in the cultural sector, which has been cut by 40%.

The cuts hurt and some organisations will close. Many people are losing
their jobs. It's awful. But I do not see what this has to do with the
courts. I don't think governments are obliged to provide jobs for everyone.
They can't. This is about politics, not the law.

In the UK for funding of the new media arts sector is moving towards an
instrumental view of digital media. This means cutting digital arts
organisations that promote experimental practice and placing what funding is
left in programmes that support conventional arts organisations in
developing their websites, digital marketing capability and train their
staff in social media for PR.

Best

Simon

On 15/06/2011 10:53, "Heiko Recktenwald" <heikorecktenwald at googlemail.com>
wrote:

> NOPE!
> 
> When the day is over you want to keep a present and why should new media
> institution have any better case than
> theaters, museums, universities, orchestras and the like?
> 
> 
> Get real,
> 
> 
> H.
> 
> 
> Am 15.06.2011 11:38, schrieb Alessandro Ludovico:
>> And then what about joining forces with the UK affected institutions,
>> trying to make a shared court challenge, or two simultaneously?
>> 
>> I'm not an expert too, but it seems more and more urgent to plan
>> relevant actions.
>> 
>> a.
>> 
>>> this may sound somewhat naive, but given that the organisations
>>> involved are not exactly 'fly-by-night' speculative or frivolous
>>> instances, but are historically significant parts of the Dutch,
>>> European and broader and international cultural, political,
>>> educational, academic and scientific landscapes, i.e. institutions of
>>> major significant cultural and national heritage, that perhaps this
>>> is an issue that needs to be taken up by a court challenge at the
>>> European level, either at the European Court of Human Rights or the
>>> European Court of Justice. It's not necessarily so that national
>>> governments have either the right, the mandate or the power to
>>> disproportionately or unreasonably erase such significant portions of
>>> their own cultural identity.
>>> 
>>> any legal experts with relevant experience/insight among the ranks of
>>> the spectrites?
>>> 
>>> greetings,
>>> 
>>> Stephen
>>> 
>>> On 14.06.2011, at 20:15, Andreas Broeckmann wrote:
>>> 
>>>>  (fwd)
>>>> 
>>>>  Last Friday the new policy plans of the new Minister were announced
>>>> and published and they are very dramatic in general for the whole
>>>> field of art and culture in The Netherlands. On the PNEK list it was
>>>> announced as:
>>>> 
>>>>  New Media Art Organisations in Netherlands lose funding.
>>>> 
>>>>  The Dutch New Media Art Organisations Steim, De Waag, Mediamatic,
>>>> V2 & NIMK are about to lose all their funding.
>>>>  The Dutch secretary of state for Culture in the Netherlands, Halbe
>>>> Zijlstra, has published his policy plan for coming years. In
>>>> contrast to the official recommendations given to him by the Culture
>>>> Advisory Board, the cutbacks will not be spread out over a number of
>>>> years, but will take immediate effect in 2013. The budget for visual
>>>> art will shrink from 53,3 to 31 million.
>>>>  Among the more damaging and destructive decisions is the complete
>>>> cutting of funding for the six leading New Media Art Organsiations
>>>> that produce, distribute and facilitate New Media Art;
>>>>  -STEIM: Independent Live electronic music centre that is
>>>> exclusively dedicated to the performing arts.
>>>>  -De WAAG: Organisation & Worklab for old and new media, developers
>>>> of open source tools, research & technology for the creative
>>>> independant industry & intermediate between art, science and media.
>>>>  -Worm: Rotterdam based laboratory, venue and studios for film,
>>>> music and internet featuring concerts, new media events, screenings,
>>>> production of film, music and software art.
>>>>  -Mediamatic: software art projects, lectures, workshops &
>>>> screenings aiming on the young generation of artists, designers &
>>>> tinkerers.
>>>>  -V2: interdisciplinary centre for art and media technology in
>>>> Rotterdam, activities include organizing presentations, exhibitions
>>>> and workshops, research and development of artworks operating in an
>>>> international network
>>>>  -NIMK: The Netherlands Media Art Institute (NIMk) promotes the wide
>>>> and unrestrained development, application and distribution of, and
>>>> reflection on, new technologies within the visual arts. Since the
>>>> Netherlands Media Art Institute came into being in 1978 an extensive
>>>> collection of video and media art has been assembled, to which new
>>>> works are constantly being added.
>>>> 
>>>>  These institutes together form the foundation for New Media Arts in
>>>> the Netherlands and forfil an important role in the International
>>>> Network that shares knowledge, exchanges, produces, distributes and
>>>> promotes various forms of New Media Art.
>>>>  For most of these organisations the budget cuts will mean their
>>>> disappearance.
>>>> 
>>>> 
>>>> 
>>>>  (fwd)
>>>> 
>>>>  BUT of course there is more to it. In the document one can read
>>>> that Architecture, Design and eCulture are fusing together in a new
>>>> fund called Creative Industry (something non of these sectors
>>>> wants). ALL organization in the 3 domains won't receive any
>>>> structural funding anymore in this plan BUT the new Fund, that is
>>>> now being structured, will likely offer the change to organizations
>>>> to get structural funding (2 to 4 years). But since this fund is not
>>>> there yet and since they are having strong debates about the role
>>>> and function, and program of this fund nothing is indicated about
>>>> this fund in the published document. So when reading the document
>>>> you get a different picture of what is being debated right now
>>>> insight the Ministry and with the 3 sectors.
>>>> The thing that should be in place for this fund are
>>>>  1. structural funding to some of the important plpl.ayers in the 3
>>>> sectors; and
>>>>  2. creating space for basic research in the 3 sectors.
>>>>  When we get this done we are still facing a hardcore economic
>>>> agenda (the Minister is a hardcore liberal) but that we can shape
>>>> and address 'creatively' since we can't and don't want to fullfill
>>>> this agenda ourselves. Dealing with the goals of the new Fund will
>>>> be a major challenge since NO ONE wants this Fund and it has NO
>>>> bearing grounds.
>>>>  Still, if you read the whole document you can see that probably
>>>> eCulture, design and architecture are coming out best if you compare
>>>> what is happening in other sectors like theatre, performing arts,
>>>> post academic education, visual arts a.s. For example all production
>>>> houses for theatre won't be funded anymore; all post-academic
>>>> organization like the Rijksacademie, Jan van Eyck and Berlage
>>>> Institute won't receive any funding anymore after 2012. This are
>>>> just some of the cuts that have been done.
>>>> 
>>>>  NIMk nevertheless, since they are not part of eCulture but the
>>>> visual arts, are serious trouble up from 2013. The Minister
>>>> indicated that he has NO responsiblity for an archive that is not
>>>> set up by the Ministry but by a foundation itself, so it's NIMk's
>>>> responsibility to deal with their archive he thinks. The same for
>>>> the Theater Instituut Nederland that won't get any funding and who
>>>> also have a large archive on theatre on theatre covering decades of
>>>> history. but it's also an archive setup and organised by the
>>>> institute itself so also here the Minister sees no responsibilities
>>>> for him.
>>>> 
>>>>  So you can imagine that I have been lobbying, having meetings last
>>>> months since we saw all of this coming, even though the result is
>>>> very unexpected in its format (bringing architecture, design and
>>>> eCulture in one new sector called Creative Industry - that nobody
>>>> wants to be related to).
>>>> 
>>>>  I keep you updated since the coming month will be essential for the
>>>> future of eCulture in the Netherlands since the new fund is now
>>>> being discussed and shaped and should be announced end of July. And
>>>> of course we think and push that this new fund will supoort some
>>>> organisations structuraly since the budget is there (eCulture is far
>>>> less cut down then any other sector, only about 15% while other
>>>> sectors face cut downs to 25 till 50%).
>>>> 
>>>>  ______________________________________________
>>>>  SPECTRE list for media culture in Deep Europe
>>>>  Info, archive and help:
>>>>  http://post.in-mind.de/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/spectre
>>> 
>>> 
>>> 
>>> 
>>> 
>>> Initiator / Director
>>> McLuhan in Europe 2011 Network
>>> ---------------------------------------------------------
>>> RE-TOUCHING McLUHAN
>>> http://mcluhan2011.eu/berlin
>>> #mcluhan2011eu
>>> Berlin Centennial Weekend | 27 - 29 May 2011
>>> Marshall McLuhan Salon | Embassy of Canada
>>> 
>>> ---------------------------------------------------------
>>> kovats at mcluhan2011.eu
>>> http://mcluhan2011.eu
>>> twitter.com/mcluhan2011eu
>>> facebook.com/mcluhan2011eu
>>> http://www.transmediale.de/Beyond/mcluhan-2011
>>> ---------------------------------------------------------
>>> 
>>> ______________________________________________
>>> SPECTRE list for media culture in Deep Europe
>>> Info, archive and help:
>>> http://post.in-mind.de/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/spectre
>> 
>> 
> 
> ______________________________________________
> SPECTRE list for media culture in Deep Europe
> Info, archive and help:
> http://post.in-mind.de/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/spectre
> 

Simon Biggs
simon at littlepig.org.uk
http://www.littlepig.org.uk/

s.biggs at eca.ac.uk
http://www.elmcip.net/
http://www.eca.ac.uk/circle/